Equipment

I Don’t Know Why It Swallowed a Fly – Weather Sealed Lens With a Fly Inside

Published June 10, 2015

I’ve been blogging about testing and taking apart camera equipment for almost a decade. Lensrentals.com has many thousand lenses these days, and they all get used frequently. When you have lots of lenses and they get used frequently, stuff gets inside them.

Usually the stuff that gets inside is dust. Our repair techs open up and clean dust out of more than 100 lenses a week. Not because the dust matters a bit in a photograph; it doesn’t. But because people still seem to think it does. People also, for reasons I can’t understand, seem to think that weather sealed lenses are less likely to get dust in them than non-weather sealed lenses. I’m not sure why they think this, but they do.

Sometimes the stuff that gets inside them is interesting and we get to blog about it. We found a spider, complete with web, inside a lens once and yesterday we got to add a new item to our ‘found inside lenses’ collection; a nice, fat, fly. And not just a fly inside a lens, but one way down deep inside a weather sealed lens. So deep that it took 4 hours of work to get it out.

The lens in question was a Canon 24-105mm f/4 IS that returned from rental looking quite normal with the renter taking equally normal photos.

Nothing unusual looking about this lens on its return.

But a quick look through the glass reveals a fairly significant problem a fly deep inside the lens. Being in the middle of the lens with lots of glass elements on either side, it was much more difficult to photograph than it was to see visually. Darryl finally came up with an arrangement that worked decently.

Canon 5DIII with MP-E 65 5x Macro lens shooting through the 24-105. Angling the light let it bounce around through the glass elements and give us decent lighting.

 

After a little trial and error, he got some decent images of the fly.

 

 

If you just dropped by to see a fly picture, you may go now. But getting the fly out of the lens turned into a 4-hour ordeal for Darryl. The pictures he took along the way do a great job of demonstrating exactly why dust will always find it’s way into a lens, so if you’d like to see that process, read on.

Darryl’s first thought was that removing the front element would let him used some compressed air to blow the fly out of the lens. We didn’t have a lot of hope that would work, but it’s quick and easy to do so it was worth a try. Next Darryl took the back off of the lens and took out the rear element, hoping that would work. It got another nice picture of the fly, still a few pieces of glass away from freedom, but otherwise didn’t accomplish anything.

 

Finally, bowing to the inevitable, Darryl did a complete disassembly of the autofocus and mechanical system, leaving the inner optical elements in the helicoid barrels.

 

The point to be made here is that there are huge openings into the inner lens through the helicoid slots. Obviously anything that gets inside the lens is free to move about to the inner elements. Dust particles, spiders, or in this case a fly, are all going to find their way down inside the lens. And weather sealing isn’t ever true sealing. There is no lens made for cameras that doesn’t have openings that air, dust, and other things can flow through. In the case of the Canon 24-105mm there’s an obvious opening through the rear of the lens.

Rear of the Canon 24-105mm showing anything that wants can get inside the lens around the rear group. A lot of lenses are similar to this one, but every lens ever made has openings.

 

Let’s get back to our fly. Now with the inner barrel removed, Darryl could peak through the helicoid openings and locate the fly between elements.

 

After a little trial and error, he was able to get some needle-nose forceps through a slot and remove the fly. (It wouldn’t blow out; apparently some fly sticky-stuff had it pretty adhered to the lens.)

 

The element could be cleaned through the slots too, and then the lens was reassembled. Because of the amount of disassembly involved, the lens had to be recentered and optically adjusted. Total repair time to get the fly out was just over 4 hours.

The takeaway message, though, is in the picture you can’t see here. We took dozens of images with the lens before taking the fly out. We shot stopped down, we shot at all parts of the zoom range. We focused close, we focused far. And in no image could we find the slightest hint that there was a fly in the lens. And you guys worry about a dust particle or two!

 

Darryl Bolin, Roger Cicala and Aaron Closz

Lensrentals.com

June, 2015

Author: Roger Cicala

I’m Roger and I am the founder of Lensrentals.com. Hailed as one of the optic nerds here, I enjoy shooting collimated light through 30X microscope objectives in my spare time. When I do take real pictures I like using something different: a Medium format, or Pentax K1, or a Sony RX1R.

Posted in Equipment
  • Torey Azure

    Really? No comments on this?

    I get how dust ends up in a lens, either from mounting the lens or just from zoom or focus action. But it’s hard for a fly to actually make its way into the actual elements.

    Your most under-appreciated blog post.

    Agreed with your statement regarding dust and most photographers obsession with lens perfection. One of my friends has the most scratched and nastiest looking front elements/glass on her lenses and her pictures are beautiful. I wouldn’t
    recommend her approach but it does tell a story of how much room for imperfection really exists in these lenses.

Follow on Feedly